Our Mercenaries
_________
P.S.: You may consider Scahill too much of a pinko since he writes for The Nation if so, try: Peter Singer. Corporate Warriors: The Rise of the Privatized Military Industry. (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2003) and “Out Sourcing War” Foreign Affairs (March 2005). Here is the abstract for the latter article, published in the house journal of the hardly pink Council on Foreign Relations:
"Private companies are becoming significant players in conflicts around the world, supplying not merely the goods but also the services of war. Although recent well-publicized incidents from Abu Ghraib to Zimbabwe have shone unaccustomed light on this new force in warfare, private military firms remain a poorly understood - and often unacknowledged - phenomenon. Mystery, myth, and conspiracy theory surround them, leaving policymakers and the public in positions of dangerous ignorance. Many key questions remain unanswered, including, What is the industry and where did it come from? What is its role in the US' largest current overseas venture, Iraq? What are the broader implications of that role? And how should policymakers respond? Only by developing a better understanding of this burgeoning industry can governments hope to get a proper hold on this newly powerful force in foreign policy. If they fail, the consequences for policy and democracy could be deeply destructive."
Labels: BushCo, Mercenaries
















5 Comments:
These mercs are not just deployed overseas- they were very much on the scene post Katrina, every bit as unaccountable on home turf!
The difference between the two is that Singer reports the facts, while Scahill freely mixes fact with half-truth, rumor, myth, and wishful thinking in order to fuel his hate stew. Take a good look at what Singer or Nic Bicanic have to say about Scahill--if you're interested in reality, that is.
Drew, I've not been able to find Singer or Bicanic saying anything about Scahill. Singer is an academic, Bicanic a film maker (the reviews of his documentary on this suggest he is not terribly critical)and Scahill a journalist. Perhaps the different genres accounts for their differences? Moreover, I think Scahill is interested in the background of some of the higher-ups in the PMC companies (like the religious zealot who is head of Balckwater) which may be more speculative than Singer, for instance, is willing to be. In any case, Singer is pretty clear that we don't know enough about these companies and that they do operate in a "grey" area outside of standard channels of law and accountability. Jim
Stan, Scahill is among the reporters who discovered the Blackwater types racing around New Orleans. I think the private security industry is in fact going to be more prevalent in the US soon too. JJ
Check out how Robert (Iraq For Sale) Greenwald is so hypocritically attacked for being a "war profiteer" by Rep. Kingston
as he testifies before Congress along with Scahill...
http://www.robertgreenwald.org/2007/05/whoa_attacked_in_congress_video.php
Post a Comment
<< Home